Hello? Is Anyone Listening? Apparently, yes.

Hello?  Is this thing on?

That’s what I used to wonder when I began this blog.  You hit publish and your words disappear off into oblivion.  Sometimes that’s a good thing.  Sometimes we just need to vent, sometimes we want to put things out there just to get them off our chests.  Sometimes a wonderful community surrounds you and supports you on your bad days.

Sometimes you say things because you really mean them and the debate that ensues is uplifting and inspiring.

Sometimes you say things to convey the growing pains of being a parent and people tell you that you are wrong.  Like Lisa Belkin of the Huffington Post.

Belkin has taken issue with my recent post on Mommyish where I explain that I am not a fan of the words win, penis and girlfriend as far as my three-year-old is concerned.  Of course it’s the word penis that is raising eyebrows.  Now I am being asked to defend my position on Huff Post Live today.  How do you think I’ll hold up?  Will I crumble?  Will I have a change of heart?  Will I stand my ground?  What do you think?


About Carinn Jade

Mother, lawyer, yogi, writer, non-sleeper. Published @NYTMotherlode. Contributor @Mommyish @Moonfrye @HuffPostLive. I like beer (not wine) & tea (not coffee) & being a contrarian.
This entry was posted in am I doing this right?, Bad mom. Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to Hello? Is Anyone Listening? Apparently, yes.

  1. This may not turn out stuck using the nook but I read not only your article but those comments too, I do not understand where they are coming your son is 3 not 6 or 7, the society on a whole is in a hurry to rob children of their innocence. Abusers are out there that doesn’t mean teaching techinal terms prevents or saves a child. In the care of Riley do pray she can go to a private school where the innocence is protected, there is time for everything and no matter what by the time they graduate they will know what from what no matter what or how they are taught. These terms of telling children everything that is none of their business seems more important thaninstructions of morals and this is where I also agree with the idea of winning, this can destroy a self esteem because we are all good at something but not line up with society judgments of worthy ie football player / cheerleaders popular over the bookworm these are unfair but society does not award the quiet workers in the background. Dont get me started on girlfriends, stand your ground please 🙂 it could rough sorry

  2. Furiously editing your son’s speech, eh? People read into things what they want to, what they need to get defensive about. I’d be surprised by the responses to your article, but for some reason, people tend to take statements of differing parenting choices as an attack on their own.

    It’s not important whether or not I agree with your personal parental “no” list. I can read beyond that, and I understand the feelings you are having—the desire to let your child grow up without being negatively influenced by words or concepts or judgements. To let him grow up slowly. I get that, and I think it is incredibly important. My favorite parenting book talks about the importance of preserving a child’s innocence for as long as possible. The author made a very important distinction, however, about the difference between innocence and naivete and between wisdom and cynicism. When he talks about preserving innocence, it’s not by keeping the child in a bubble away from the realities of the world, and it’s certainly not by introducing words or concepts too early just because they’ll come up someday. Rather it’s done by presenting and discussing what inevitably comes along in a way that retains compassion and openness and protects from cynicism. A good example for this is with your example of “winning” and “losing”. Yes, winning and losing are concepts that will come up frequently in life in both healthy and unhealthy ways. That doesn’t mean your 3 year old needs to be thinking about it. But since it’s been introduced, how do you keep it positive and from becoming a thing? By being honest, I think. Three year old honest, anyway. And by doing a little casual redirecting.

    So what are you going to do?

    • I think it’s funny that I was clear I don’t consider these words “bad” words, I would have never used the word “ban” and I have never told him NOT to use these words. I simply have not introduced them to him. And that is my choice. I’m going to stand my ground. What you said about letting them grow up slowly, at their own pace, is at the heart of my original post.

  3. I don’t understand why Belkin took such a dislike to it.

    Sure, she may not agree with what you’re saying – but it’s really no business of hers what words you do or do not want you child saying. I suppose she’s responding to the article being posted on a public forum yet the fact remains, it is up to you what words you want your child should say

    The extension is your reaction to it. It’s not as though you are writing into the pre-school asking them for be closed, or scolding the teacher for letting him hear these words (as I’ve experienced) – you are simply stating what you want for your son as, no doubt, part of your own growth and learning. You accept that many of these are simply facets of his life that he will now learn to live with and cope with. Especially the idea of “winning.” Children are their own people. You may foster a degree of trying and effort, but simple children (especially boys) just want to win. It’s out of your hands and it comes across that you accept that (though don’t agree with).

    I think Belkin should’ve focused more on the viewpoint than the examples because, for mine, she missed the mark there.

  4. muddledmom says:

    Stand your ground. Every parent has words they prefer over words they don’t. Every person has words they prefer over words they don’t. Mom-101 just wrote a post about that. I have a friend who gags when you say the word “moist.” When my kids were little, I taught them to say “make noise” instead of farting because I didn’t want them to run around in public yelling, “She farted!” Guess what? A great parenting decision! They would giggle and talk about it and no one knew what they were talking about. I didn’t teach my son “vagina” until I had the sex talk with him at age 9 also because I didn’t want him running around saying it all the time. Boys do that. He did know penis and he talked about it all the time! So what if you don’t want your three-year-old saying that? That’s the reason I didn’t teach my son the rest of the private parts.

    As far as winning, what you wrote sounds to me like it’s not exactly forbidden. My kids get trophies for every damn thing they do and it is sickening. I’ve posted about how I hate this. My kids even ask before they commit to something, “Will I get a trophy?” In a parent’s eyes, a parent who is trying to teach her children that making effort and learning skill are better for them in the long run, I think you were on the mark.

    But don’t be so defensive either. Just because Lisa Belkin asked you to defend your position doesn’t mean she doesn’t agree. Or did she really say that?

  5. Hmmm…I’m gonna go with Be flattered that your writing is being read and evaluated. But on a personal note, all of us moms have hot-button words/issues when it comes to our kids. As long as your rules aren’t too over-the-top or suffocating for your kid, then do your thing. Our little ones are bound to figure out all of it – good, bad, icky – and there’s such a small window of innocence.

  6. mamabear73 says:

    I agree with lessthanperfectmama. Be flattered that it’s being read (no such thing as bad publicity, right? 🙂 ). And also, yes of course we all have hot-button issues, preferences, etc. regarding our kids. And I certainly can vouch firsthand that some of the things that bug me turn out to have little to do with logic. Having read the articles, I think that Belkin missed the point. Yeah, so we use the words “penis” and “vagina” in our house. But those are personal views/preferences. It seems to me that what your article was really about was the bigger issue of the process of letting go of our being the only/primary reference points for our kids. When my daughter came home from camp singing, “I’m sexy and I know it!” (actually, “I’m SAX-y and I know it!”) and wiggling her little behind, it was truly brought home to me that there is a whole world out there that she will be exposed to, whether I like it or not. What’s important is what I do with that. Keep up your wonderful, insightful writing. The conversation will go on!

    • You really hit the nail on the head here and I cringe thinking about all that is still to come (I’m SAX-y and I know it!). Thank you for your support! Thankfully I think the discussion on HuffPostLive went well and the moderator was great. The conversation continues!

  7. Stand your ground. There is no right or wrong, it’s a matter of choice. I know my sons aren’t going to be calling it “their bean” when they’re 20. No harm.

Share your brilliance

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s